COTTINGHAM & BUTLERbroker
Benefits brokerage · plan year 2024 · page 1
Reported compensation · 2024
$2.6M
COTTINGHAM & BUTLER was paid $2,643,105 in commissions and fees across 123 employer benefit plans in 2024, as reported on Schedule A ($355,062 of it as fees rather than commissions).
Client movement · 2023 → 2024
Gained 47 client planslost 36
won Naviant, Inc.
won K. Z., Inc.
won Andis Company
lost Bard Materials
Computed from Schedule A filings for 2023 and 2024; a "lost" client may have switched, filed late, or stopped reporting compensation. Track movement across every firm: Plan Ledger Pro.
Client plans · 2024123
Industrial Technologies and Services, LLC NC$319,602
Long Iron Services, LLC. IL$248,959
Cordia LLC AZ$191,743
Cheeseman LLC OH$127,079
Madison Newspapers, Inc. WI$115,155
Lee Enterprises, Incorporated IA$115,155
Paschall Truck Lines, Inc. KY$108,414
Rockline Industries, Inc. WI$104,835
Ay McDonald Industries Inc IA$82,182
Millis Transfer, LLC. WI$75,111
W.D. Larson Companies LTD Inc. MN$60,244
Arcserve LLC MN$58,091
Prince Manufacturing Corporation SD$57,399
Heart of America Management LLC IL$56,511
Grand Island Express, Inc. NE$55,777
First Supply LLC WI$33,971
Thor Industries, Inc. IN$30,591
Amana Society, Inc IA$30,000
Maui Jim, Inc. IL$29,475
Karls Transport Inc. WI$27,797
Education Analytics, Inc. WI$25,589
Martin's Bulk Milk Service, Inc. WI$24,429
Nord Gear Corporation WI$23,681
Kennesaw Transportation, Inc. GA$22,778
Johnson Feed, Inc. SD$22,742
Van Wyk, Inc. IA$21,561
Cameron Mitchell Restaurants OH$19,059
Lange Companies, Inc. MO$18,621
Lee Enterprises, Incorporated IA$18,118
Quality Liquid Feeds Inc. WI$17,502
Urban Land Interests, LLC WI$16,563
Msa Professional Services, Inc. WI$15,685
Hirschbach Motor Lines, Inc. IA$15,107
Midland Information Resources Company IA$15,098
James River Carriers VA$14,495
Altorfer Inc IA$14,097
Nucara Management Group, Inc. IA$13,749
Steindler Orthopedic Clinic PLC IA$13,342
Empirical Technology, Inc. SD$13,009
Menominee Indian Tribe of Wisconsin WI$12,373
Omega Systems Consultants, LLC PA$12,102
Fox Communities Credit Union WI$11,852
Pbbs Equipment Corporation WI$11,538
Patriot Transportation Holding, Inc . FL$11,337
Midwest Products and Engineering, Inc. WI$10,186
Milk Source LLC WI$9,632
Centro, Inc. IA$9,472
Honkamp Krueger & Co., P.C. IA$9,245
Akrs Equipment Solutions NE$8,942
Hendrick Manufacturing Co. PA$8,469
Decker Truck Line, Inc. IA$8,129
Switchgear Power Systems LLC WI$8,104
J&D Tube Benders, Inc. WI$8,092
Cemen Tech Inc IA$8,082
Lee Enterprises, Incorporated IA$6,945
Oak View Farms, LLC IA$6,839
Wick Building Systems, Inc. WI$6,512
The Potato King, Inc. WI$6,447
Naviant, Inc. WI$6,304
Ps Seasoning & Spices, Inc WI$6,093
K2D Incorporated CO$5,895
Pointe Precision, Inc. WI$5,802
Society Insurance WI$5,611
Prince Manufacturing Corporation SD$5,525
Oshkosh Door Company WI$4,989
Ortho Molecular Products IL$4,915
St. Ambrose University IA$4,786
Daniels Sharpsmart, Inc. IL$4,759
Annex Wealth Management WI$4,713
Lange Companies, Inc. MO$4,691
Wisco Industries, Inc. WI$4,370
The Scharine Group Inc. WI$4,178
D & M Carriers Inc. OK$4,133
United Stars Holdings, Inc. WI$4,096
Fremont Farms of Iowa LLP IA$4,057
Prince Manufacturing Corporation SD$3,933
First Equity Holdings, LLC OH$3,917
Jones Sign Company WI$3,872
Lincoln Wood Products, Inc. WI$3,566
Hoffman Transportation, Inc. IL$3,466
K. C. Nielsen, LTD IA$3,347
Rei Enterprises, LLC IA$3,226
Food Express, Inc. CA$3,217
K. Z., Inc. IN$3,191
Andis Company WI$3,146
Bethany Manor dba Bethany Life IA$3,105
Sign-Zone, LLC MN$2,869
Bcp Transportation Inc. WI$2,758
Hibu Inc. IA$2,721
J Rayl Transport, Inc. OH$2,655
Resourceone Global L L C MO$2,571
Spahn & Rose Lumber Co. IA$2,554
Weconnect Global, LLC. WI$2,526
The Lowlands Group LLC WI$2,524
University of Wisconsin Credit Union WI$2,382
Lee Enterprises Incorporated IA$2,322
Hill Brothers Transportation, Inc. NE$2,294
Research Products Corporation WI$2,164
Source: DOL Form 5500 Schedule A Part I broker compensation, plan year 2024. Related legal entities grouped under the COTTINGHAM & BUTLER brand.