COTTINGHAM AND BUTLER INSURANCEbroker

Benefits brokerage · plan year 2024 · page 1

Reported compensation · 2024

$5.2M

COTTINGHAM AND BUTLER INSURANCE was paid $5,228,215 in commissions and fees across 111 employer benefit plans in 2024, as reported on Schedule A ($614,292 of it as fees rather than commissions).

Client movement · 2023 → 2024
Gained 37 client planslost 21
won Cemen Tech Inc.
won Tsd Logistics, Inc.
won American Producers Supply Co., Inc.
won C. E. Niehoff & Co.
won Amston Supply, Inc.
won Panama Transfer, Inc.
lost Fiducial, Inc.
lost Hirschbach Motor Lines, Inc.
lost Engineered Seal Products, Inc.
lost J Rayl Transport, Inc.
lost 4G Clinical, LLC
lost Bettcher Industries, Inc.
Computed from Schedule A filings for 2023 and 2024; a "lost" client may have switched, filed late, or stopped reporting compensation. Track movement across every firm: Plan Ledger Pro.

Client plans · 2024111
Beelman Truck Company IL$306,252
Carter Express, Inc. IN$244,334
Western Flyer Express, LLC OK$204,132
Crosby US Acquisition Corp. OK$167,773
Crosby US Acquisition Corp. OK$167,773
Crosby US Acquisition Corp. OK$167,773
Crosby US Acquisition Corp. OK$167,773
Crosby US Acquisition Corp. OK$167,773
Cameron Mitchell Restaurants OH$158,863
Lily Transportation Corp. MA$152,616
Heartland Express, Inc of Iowa IA$148,291
Hmd Trucking Inc. IL$122,658
Gp Transportation Co. IL$117,229
Etnyre International, LTD. IL$109,408
Halvor Lines, Inc. WI$105,801
Raymond Chevrolet IL$94,932
Saginaw Chippewa Indian Tribe of Mi MI$94,068
Long Iron Services, LLC. IL$91,805
Acteon US Holdings, Inc. TX$88,837
Martin's Bulk Milk Service, Inc. WI$86,317
Eakas Corporation IL$84,068
Weconnect Global, LLC. WI$78,425
Crosby US Acquisition Corp. OK$77,494
Midwest Products and Engineering, Inc. WI$72,929
Hibu Inc. IA$68,962
Zeller Innovations dba Roomready IL$66,979
Rjw Logistics Group Inc. IL$65,734
Ay McDonald Industries Inc IA$64,371
American Central Transport, Inc. MO$64,330
Rihm Family Companies MN$63,971
Chemoil Energy Services LLC OK$55,497
Wel Companies, Inc. WI$53,704
Running Supply, Inc. MN$51,978
Akrs Equipment Solutions NE$51,257
California Overland LTD MN$47,044
American Producers Supply Co., Inc. OH$40,473
Triad Technologies LLC OH$40,306
Hgc Construction Co. OH$38,757
Bull Moose Heavy Haul, Inc. IA$38,495
Crst, the Transportation Solution, Inc. IA$38,100
Panama Transfer, Inc. IA$37,875
Aim Leasing Company OH$37,701
James River Carriers VA$37,112
Fortune Transportation MN$34,993
Kimrad Transport, LP TX$33,536
Storey Trucking Company, Inc. AL$33,383
Crosby US Acquisition Corp. OK$33,188
Crosby US Acquisition Corp. OK$33,188
South East Carriers, Inc. TN$33,171
Nucara Management Group, Inc. IA$33,071
Midwestone Financial Group Inc IA$31,596
Bill Whitters Construction, Inc. IA$31,444
Le Claire Manufacturing Co. IA$31,382
Caledonia Haulers, Inc. MN$28,101
Lgt Transport, LLC NE$27,694
Nucara Management Group, Inc. IA$27,134
Fourth Enterprises LLC Hot Schedule TX$26,746
Thrifty Drug Stores , Inc. MN$24,650
Midwest Ent Alliance, PLLC IL$24,567
Citizens Community Federal National Association WI$24,366
Calimira, LLC. OH$24,035
Iowa Rotocast Plastics, Inc. IA$23,609
Cit Trucks, LLC IL$23,133
Paschall Truck Lines, Inc. KY$22,666
Bcp Transportation Inc. WI$21,900
Coker Tire Company TN$21,626
Semo Milling LLC MO$21,619
Braswell Milling Company, Inc. NC$20,344
Wesley Willows Corporation IL$20,166
Zanini Tennessee, Inc. TN$20,089
Simantel Group, LTD. IL$19,907
Cemen Tech Inc. IA$18,023
Seats Incorporated WI$17,982
Quincy Recylce Paper Inc IL$15,678
Great Plains Transport, Inc. ND$14,520
Cerebral Palsy, Inc. WI$13,690
Enterprise Properties Inc NE$13,326
Lake Book Manufacturing, Inc. IL$13,102
Woolf Distributing Company, Inc. IL$12,219
The Homeless Alliance OK$11,231
Lands End, Inc. WI$10,175
St. Croix Chippewa Indians of Wisconsin WI$9,817
Amston Supply, Inc. WI$9,764
Moore Holding Company ND$9,534
C. E. Niehoff & Co. IL$7,917
Tsd Logistics, Inc. TX$6,764
Devenish Nutrition MN$6,422
Minot Builders Supply Association ND$5,485
Kalle USA, LLC IL$4,645
Wacker Neuson America Corporation WI$3,540
Moore Holding Company ND$3,447
Moore Holding Company ND$3,270
Moore Holding Company ND$2,862
Goggin Warehousing, LLC TN$2,531
Moore Holding Company ND$2,461
Aldridge Electric, Inc. IL$2,451
Morrison Brothers Company IA$2,405
K. C. Nielsen, LTD IA$2,313
Moeller Trucking, Inc. OH$2,221
Moeller Trucking, Inc. OH$1,667

Source: DOL Form 5500 Schedule A Part I broker compensation, plan year 2024. Related legal entities grouped under the COTTINGHAM AND BUTLER INSURANCE brand.