Plan Ledger DOL Form 5500 · updated monthly

Merchants Mutual Insurance Company401(k)

MERCHANTS MUTUAL CAPITAL ACCUMULATION PLAN · BUFFALO, NY · plan year 2025

Reported admin expense ratio · 2025
0.03%

Peer grade: A- · admin costs + employer contributions vs same-size plans · how grading works

Merchants Mutual Insurance Company reported $22,755 in plan administrative expenses for 2025: 0.03% of average plan assets, lower than ~75% of peers. Employer contributions averaged $5,514 per active participant. This ratio covers administrative expenses reported on the plan's Schedule H only; fund-level expense ratios are not included in public structured data — see methodology.

Across the 3 years on file its reported administrative ratio rose from 0.02% to 0.03%. The plan sits in the $50M–$250M size bracket, benchmarked here against 3,004 comparable plans and shown alongside other finance & insurance employers. By assets it is the 935th-largest of 5,664 plans among New York employers on file, and the 1,177th of 4,822 in finance & insurance. In 2025, employees put in $1.72 for every $1.00 the employer contributed.

Plan summary
Net assets, end of year$84,143,910
Participants with balances433
Active participants321
Employer contributions$1,769,952
Employee contributions$3,036,175
Employer contribution per active participant$5,514
Average account balance$194,328
Benefits paid to participants$11,779,920
Plan auditUnmodified (clean) audit opinion
AuditorDOPKINS & COMPANY LLP
Plan history4
Yearassets · accounts · employer contribution
2025$84.1M · 433 accts · $1.8M emplr
2024$79.1M · 438 accts · $1.8M emplr
2023$70.4M · 433 accts · $1.8M emplr
2022$64.3M · 429 accts · $1.8M emplr
Administrative expenses, itemized · 2025
Recordkeeping & contract admin$22,455
Total administrative$22,755
The Merchants Mutual Insurance Company 401(k) match · 2025
Employer contribution per active participant$5,514
Median for plans this size$4,034
2025$5,514 per active participant
2024$5,418 per active participant
2023$5,284 per active participant
2022$5,556 per active participant

Merchants Mutual Insurance Company's 2025 employer contribution ran above the $4,034 median for plans its size. Filings report dollars actually contributed, not the match formula; the formula itself (for example, 50% of the first 6% of pay) lives in the plan's summary plan description from HR.

What these fees cost you

Annual cost at the plan's reported 2025 administrative ratio, against the median plan its size; fund expense ratios are extra. Compare any plan.

Service providers · 20253
CHARLES SCHWAB & CO., INC. · Investment advisory (participants) · Securities brokerage$324
QDRO CONSULTANTS COMPANY, LLC$300

Compensation shown is direct payments from plan assets reported on Schedule C. Providers paid through fund revenue-sharing appear as indirect.

Administrative cost history4
2025$22,755 · 0.03%
2024$18,124 · 0.02%
2023$22,523 · 0.03%
2022$15,965 · 0.02%
Same employer
Similar plansFinance & Insurance · New York
Orbimed Advisors, L.L.C. NY$86.0M · 0.01%
Equiniti Trust Company NY$85.5M · 0.01%
American Securities LLC NY$83.8M · 0.08%
Intesa Sanpaolo S.P.A. NY$82.2M · 0.08%
Hiscox Inc. NY$82.1M · 0.20%

Why are you looking at this plan?

Compare

Source: U.S. Department of Labor, Form 5500 series, EIN 160550140 · Verify on EFAST2 · Amounts are as reported by the plan sponsor for the plan year shown.